Phil: I'm sorry, but kissing someone outside of a relationship is a big deal and you should fess up right away.
Haley: You told them?!
Claire: Yes! Yes, they told us everything, and I can't believe you did that!
Haley: Well, I'm sorry, but Dylan was a huge part of my life...
Claire: You kissed Dylan?! That's your secret?
Haley: [gasps] You tricked me!