James: Gary Blauman? I... hate... that I once thought I loved Gary Blauman.
Lily: Ooh, this sounds good.
James: Gary's the guy that I had an affair with. Tom found out, threw me out of the house, and now the kids are from a broken home. Because of Gary Blauman, everything that matters to me is gone.
Barney: I got that beat. So I was ordering fries...
Ted: Wait, wait, wait. Blauman's gay? Then that means that night, the real battle was between Blauman and the girl. And the prize was this guy.
Marshall: Figured something out.
Barney: Keep telling yourself that.