Eleanor: Okay, man. We got questions. First off, how can we possibly trust you?
Michael: You can't. But you have to. Logically, you shouldn't but you have no choice. I mean, I wouldn't, if I were you. It's a crazy thing to do.
Chidi: But you gotta. What happens if we don't?
Michael: Most likely, I reboot you once more, you figure it out again, Vicky tells my boss, he shuts everything down. I get punished, you end up spending the rest of eternity in the real Bad Place, up to your necks in a volcano full of scorpions.