Adrian Monk: Alice. We know how you did it. The Christmas gift exchange was your idea. It was easy to make sure that the captain picked Terry's name.
Captain Stottlemeyer: Yeah, I remember. I was the last one to choose and there was one name left.
Adrian Monk: The day of the party, you brought poisoned bottle into the office. You dropped it off at the front desk. It was addressed to Captain Stottlemeyer.
Captain Stottlemeyer: And you know I don't drink port.
Adrian Monk: And at some point, probably during the party, you snuck into the Captain's office and you stole the gift that he had brought in for Terry.
Natalie: When the captain couldn't find it, you suggested replacing it with the bottle. The poisoned bottle.
Adrian Monk: It was like a magician doing sleight of hand. You had everybody looking the wrong way. It was brilliant.