Claire: Phil, honey. Do you remember when you broke your arm when we were first dating?
Phil: Yeah, uh, when I slipped on the ice.
Claire: Right. That's so weird. Because in this picture, you're sitting with Denise and you have a broken arm, so-
Phil: Yeah, that's- That's weird.
Claire: So you were still dating her when you started dating me?
Phil: No.
Claire: Phil?
Phil: Yeah. Maybe. There was a time, a little overlap when, uh, I was trying to break things off with Denise.
Denise: You took me to Santa Fe.
Claire: Santa Fe? Phil, you told me that was your father.
Phil: Okay, I know the pain is fresh, but the lie is really old.