[flashback to Lily, Marshall, Barney and Robin at MacLaren's after Ted left:]
Lily: Well, I got it. You see that silk scarf? I'm going to steal it.
Zoey: Can I help you?
Lily: Yeah. Yeah! My name is Lily Aldrin. I'm a friend of Ted Mosby's, so you better...
Zoey: You're Lily Aldrin? The painter?!
Lily: Well, yeah.
Zoey: You're amazing! I bought a bunch of your paintings online.
Lily: That was you?!
Zoey: Yeah.
Lily: Oh! Thanks!