Marshall: So, by the way, I have to tell you something. I invited Jenkins.
Ted: Jenkins? No way.
Future Ted: [v.o.] We'd all started hearing about Jenkins a few weeks earlier.
[flashback to Marshall arriving at the apartment:]
Marshall: You guys will not believe what Jenkins did this time.
Ted: Who's Jenkins?
Lily: Oh, he's this hilarious new lawyer at Marshall's office.
Marshall: Hilarious! Okay, so, there's this jar of maraschino cherries in the fridge at work, so Jenkins says, "200 bucks, I'll eat the whole jar." So we give Jenkins 200 bucks, and Jenkins ate the whole jar! [laughing]