Lily: Finish your story.
Ted: What? That's it! It was just one kiss in the restaurant.
Lily: Why did you say "in the restaurant"? Did you kiss somewhere else?
Ted: Like where? In a tree? No, Lily, we did not make out in a tree! What's with this one?
Marshall: Oh, Ted. What did you do?
[flashback to Ted and Karen kissing as they reach his apartment]
Lily: Oh.
Barney: Oh, Ted, how could you? [high-fives Ted]