Jen: Actually you know what it was? I remember him coming across as kind of a player.
Ted: Me?
All: Ted?
Jen: Yeah. We were all sitting over there... [points to a table]
[2002:]
Jen: And here's a picture of my cats dressed up like Batman villains. You've got the Joker, the Riddler, Mr. Freeze...
Lily: What about Cat Woman?
Jen: Yeah, that would've been good.
Barney: Psst! Ted! [points his head towards a woman at the bar]
Ted: [looks over] Nice.
[2009:]
Ted: Wait, wait, wait. No, no, no! I remember that. I was not checking out a girl.
[2002:]
Barney: Psst, Ted. [points his head to Mustache Marshall at the bar]
Ted: Nice.
[2009:]
Ted: We were checking out Mustache Marshall.
All: Ah.